Showing posts with label cognitive dissonance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cognitive dissonance. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 9, 2026

Beliefs Blessings and Woes

 The texts from the Roman Catholic Lectionary today challenge us to prepare for the “cognitive dissonance” between our beliefs of good life and the woes of the anawim.

Answers for the Anawim


In the Reading from the First Letter to the Corinthians, Paul offers Advice to Virgins and Widows.


* [7:1–7] References to Paul’s own behavior (1 Cor 7:7–8) suggest that his celibate way of life and his preaching to the unmarried (cf. 1 Cor 7:25–35) have given some the impression that asceticism within marriage, i.e., suspension of normal sexual relations, would be a laudable ideal. Paul points to their experience of widespread immorality to caution them against overestimating their own strength (1 Cor 7:2); as individuals they may not have the particular gift that makes such asceticism feasible (1 Cor 7:7) and hence are to abide by the principle to be explained in 1 Cor 7:17–24.

* [7:17–24] On the ground that distinct human conditions are less significant than the whole new existence opened up by God’s call, Paul urges them to be less concerned with changing their states of life than with answering God’s call where it finds them. The principle applies both to the married state (1 Cor 7:1–16) and to the unmarried (1 Cor 7:25–38).

* [7:25–28] Paul is careful to explain that the principle of 1 Cor 7:17 does not bind under sin but that present earthly conditions make it advantageous for the unmarried to remain as they are (1 Cor 7:28). These remarks must be complemented by the statement about “particular gifts” from 1 Cor 7:7.

* [7:29–31] The world…is passing away: Paul advises Christians to go about the ordinary activities of life in a manner different from those who are totally immersed in them and unaware of their transitoriness. (1 Corinthians, CHAPTER 7 | USCCB, n.d.)


Psalm 45 proclaims majestic beauty is a sign of the future prosperity of the royal house.


* [Psalm 45] A song for the Davidic king’s marriage to a foreign princess from Tyre in Phoenicia. The court poet sings (Ps 45:2, 18) of God’s choice of the king (Ps 45:3, 8), of his role in establishing divine rule (Ps 45:4–8), and of his splendor as he waits for his bride (Ps 45:9–10). The woman is to forget her own house when she becomes wife to the king (Ps 45:11–13). Her majestic beauty today is a sign of the future prosperity of the royal house (Ps 45:14–17). The Psalm was retained in the collection when there was no reigning king, and came to be applied to the king who was to come, the messiah. (Psalms, PSALM 45 | USCCB, n.d.)


The Gospel of Luke presents the Sermon on the Plain.


* [6:20–26] The introductory portion of the sermon consists of blessings and woes that address the real economic and social conditions of humanity (the poor—the rich; the hungry—the satisfied; those grieving—those laughing; the outcast—the socially acceptable). By contrast, Matthew emphasizes the religious and spiritual values of disciples in the kingdom inaugurated by Jesus (“poor in spirit,” Mt 5:3; “hunger and thirst for righteousness,” Mt 5:6). In the sermon, blessed extols the fortunate condition of persons who are favored with the blessings of God; the woes, addressed as they are to the disciples of Jesus, threaten God’s profound displeasure on those so blinded by their present fortunate situation that they do not recognize and appreciate the real values of God’s kingdom. In all the blessings and woes, the present condition of the persons addressed will be reversed in the future. (Luke, CHAPTER 6 | USCCB, n.d.)



David Crawford has read the Sermon on the Plain in several translations in the hope to gain a new, Spirit-led perspective. The Message translation opens with:


You’re blessed when you’ve lost it all. God’s kingdom is there for the finding.


But it was the last part that really spoke to him:


But it’s trouble ahead if you think you have it made. What you have is all you’ll ever get.


And it’s trouble ahead if you’re satisfied with yourself. Your self will not satisfy you for long.


And it’s trouble ahead if you think life’s all fun and games. There’s suffering to be met, and you’re going to meet it.


There’s trouble ahead when you live only for the approval of others, saying what flatters them, doing what indulges them. Popularity contests are not truth contests—look how many scoundrel preachers were approved by your ancestors! Your task is to be true, not popular.


I am embarrassed to think how often I let anxieties take control of me, and in the process take my focus away from the One who faithfully provides all I need. I am embarrassed to think how many times I’ve viewed my successes as the result of my own creativity, intelligence, or effort, and then fail to be appropriately grateful. I could go on and on, but you get the idea.


Loving God, you love me and provide all I need. Forgive me the many times that I forget to thank you, that I fail to trust in you. I surrender my anxieties and fears to you. Let me find your joy as I serve you by serving others, as I love you by loving others. Thank you for everything. Amen. (Crawford, n.d.)



Don Schwager quotes “Jesus, though rich, became poor for us,” by Ambrose of Milan, 339-397 A.D.


"'Blessed,' it says, 'are the poor.' Not all the poor are blessed, for poverty is neutral. The poor can be either good or evil, unless, perhaps, the blessed pauper is to be understood as he whom the prophet described, saying, 'A righteous poor man is better than a rich liar' (Proverbs 19:22). Blessed is the poor man who cried and whom the Lord heard (Psalm 34:6). Blessed is the man poor in offense. Blessed is the man poor in vices. Blessed is the poor man in whom the prince of this world (John 14:30) finds nothing. Blessed is the poor man who is like that poor Man who, although he was rich, became poor for our sake (2 Corinthians 8:9). Matthew fully revealed this when he said, 'Blessed are the poor in spirit' (Matthew 5:3). One poor in spirit is not puffed up, is not exalted in the mind of his own flesh. This beatitude is first, when I have laid aside every sin, and I have taken off all malice, and I am content with simplicity, destitute of evils. All that remains is that I regulate my conduct. For what good does it do me to lack worldly goods, unless I am meek and gentle?" (excerpt from EXPOSITION OF THE GOSPEL OF LUKE 5.53-54) (Schwager, n.d.)



Friar Jude Winkler comments on the texts for today. In Paul’s time the world was believed to end marked by resurrection of the dead.  There may be little time before Jesus returns and people should remain in the state you are in. There is not time to change status. Then time went by and Jesus would return like a thief in the night so always be ready. The Beatitudes in Luke are set on the plain. In Matthew, they are part of the Sermon on the Mount. The format in Luke of four blessings and four curses is the more traditional pattern of most formulas in the bible. Matthew offers very spiritual blessings and Luke presents the poor in reality. In Luke, Jesus reaches out to the “anawim”, the financially and spiritually poor who have no security of their own. They were ready to embrace Jesus but the rich, already fully content, rejected Him. Friar Jude urges us to recognize our brokenness and to hold on to God for dear life.


The Word Among Us Meditation on Luke 6:20-26 comments that Jesus wants all his children to be filled with his blessings. He wants the hungry to be filled, both spiritually and materially. And he wants the well-fed to continue to prosper but also to have his heart of compassion and provide for those who are poor.


As we make Jesus our primary focus, as we seek to be filled with his love above all else, we’ll find our priorities changing. We’ll no longer be content only with meeting our own needs. Our eyes will be more opened to those living in want, and we’ll want to help them. We’ll see how empty a life centered only on ourselves truly is. We’ll see how it is a life of “woe” even here and now.


So fill yourself with Jesus. And let him help you fill the needs of those around you.


“Lord, teach me to be generous to others as you have been generous to me!” (Meditation on Luke 6:20-26, n.d.)




Brian McLaren normalizes painful experiences of doubt. For many of us, faith is our map of reality, our map of the universe. It tells us where we are, where we’ve been, where we’re going, where to turn. But as soon as our trusted map stops matching reality, we feel disoriented. We have no idea where to turn, what to do, how to survive.


This terror is especially real for people … who were taught that God is an almighty supreme being who demands absolute perfection and submission, a strict and demanding father, and a tough and exacting judge. Yes, we were also taught God is loving, gracious, and forgiving, but the one requirement God demands above all others is precisely the thing that doubters struggle with most: God demands firm, unwavering faith, which we understood to mean correct beliefs. To question those beliefs throws open the terrifying possibility that God might at any moment turn against us, punish us, reject us, maybe even send us to hell if we don’t get our beliefs straight and hold them tight, without doubt…. 


Doubt can breach the psychological fortress in which we’ve felt safe, tear up the internal map by which we’ve navigated the world, and threaten to separate us from God’s favor and love. (McLaren, n.d.)


We are grateful to the Spirit for awakening our understanding of the real economic and social conditions of humanity and guiding our response as people anointed in Baptism as priest, prophet, and leader in our environment. 



References

Crawford, D. (n.d.). Daily Reflection. Creighton On Line Ministries. Retrieved September 9, 2026, from https://onlineministries.creighton.edu/daily-reflections/daily-reflection-september-9-2026 

Luke, CHAPTER 6 | USCCB. (n.d.). Daily Bible Readings, Audio and Video Every Morning | USCCB. Retrieved September 9, 2026, from https://bible.usccb.org/bible/luke/6?20 

McLaren, B. (n.d.). The Cost of Doubt. Center for Action and Contemplation. Retrieved September 9, 2026, from https://cac.org/daily-meditations/the-cost-of-doubt/ 

Meditation on Luke 6:20-26. (n.d.). The Word Among Us: Homepage. Retrieved September 9, 2026, from https://wau.org/meditations/2026/09/09/1665864/ 

1 Corinthians, CHAPTER 7 | USCCB. (n.d.). Daily Bible Readings, Audio and Video Every Morning | USCCB. Retrieved September 9, 2026, from https://bible.usccb.org/bible/1corinthians/7?25 

Psalms, PSALM 45 | USCCB. (n.d.). Daily Bible Readings, Audio and Video Every Morning | USCCB. Retrieved September 9, 2026, from https://bible.usccb.org/bible/psalms/45?11 

Schwager, D. (n.d.). Blessed Are You Poor - Yours Is the Kingdom of God. Daily Scripture Readings and Meditations – Daily Scripture Readings and Meditations. Retrieved September 9, 2026, from https://www.dailyscripture.net/daily-meditation/ 



Wednesday, September 15, 2021

Prayer in Sorrow

The texts from the Roman Catholic Lectionary (CCCB selection) today resonate with our struggle with sorrow.
Prayer and Sorrow(https://www.michelangelo.org/images/artworks/pieta.jpg) 
  The reading from the Letter to the Hebrews states that ‘Jesus offered up prayers and supplications’.

* [5:6–8] The author of Hebrews is the only New Testament writer to cite Ps 110:4, here and in Heb 7:17, 21, to show that Jesus has been called by God to his role as priest. Heb 5:7–8 deal with his ability to sympathize with sinners, because of his own experience of the trials and weakness of human nature, especially fear of death. In his present exalted state, weakness is foreign to him, but he understands what we suffer because of his previous earthly experience.1 

Psalm 31 is a prayer and praise for deliverance from enemies.

* [Psalm 31] A lament (Ps 31:2–19) with a strong emphasis on trust (Ps 31:4, 6, 15–16), ending with an anticipatory thanksgiving (Ps 31:20–24). As is usual in laments, the affliction is couched in general terms. The psalmist feels overwhelmed by evil people but trusts in the “God of truth” (Ps 31:6).2 

  In the Gospel of Luke, Mary learns of her sorrow in the presentation of Jesus in the Temple.

* [2:35] (And you yourself a sword will pierce): Mary herself will not be untouched by the various reactions to the role of Jesus (Lk 2:34). Her blessedness as mother of the Lord will be challenged by her son who describes true blessedness as “hearing the word of God and observing it” (Lk 11:27–28 and Lk 8:20–21).3
 

The Gospel of John shares her mission at the Crucifixion of Jesus.

* [19:26–27] This scene has been interpreted literally, of Jesus’ concern for his mother; and symbolically, e.g., in the light of the Cana story in Jn 2 (the presence of the mother of Jesus, the address woman, and the mention of the hour) and of the upper room in Jn 13 (the presence of the beloved disciple; the hour). Now that the hour has come (Jn 19:28), Mary (a symbol of the church?) is given a role as the mother of Christians (personified by the beloved disciple); or, as a representative of those seeking salvation, she is supported by the disciple who interprets Jesus’ revelation; or Jewish and Gentile Christianity (or Israel and the Christian community) are reconciled.4 

Cindy Murphy McMahon concludes that Our God – Jesus, the Christ – knew unspeakable horror, and He conquered it. His Blessed Mother knew soul-crushing sorrow, and she survived through the grace of God. Their love and care for us knows no limits and shows us that nothing can fully console and heal us except faith, hope and love. And the greatest of these is love.

Still, my mind and heart go to what she must have been feeling, the intense pain and suffering that she endured, despite her immensely strong faith. And at this time, in this place in history, as images of the pain and suffering that thousands of people endured 20 years ago on Sept. 11, 2001, flood our televisions, radios, newspapers and online news outlets once again, and also in some ways anew, we see modern-day mothers and other family members awash in anguish. The mothers of the first responders who perished; the wives, husbands and children of the airline passengers; the friends, brothers, sisters, fathers, mothers, and more, of those who had gone to work in the Twin Towers that fateful day – they knew, they still know, the excruciating pain of losing loved ones and the deep sorrow of injustice.5 

Don Schwager quotes “Mary stood at the cross with her Son Jesus,” by Ambrose of Milan, 339-397 A.D. He comments that Jesus, in his grief and suffering, did not forget his mother. He entrusted her care to John, as well as John to her. No loss, no suffering can keep us from the love of Christ (Romans 8:35-39). Paul the Apostle says that love bears all things, believes all things, hopes all things, endures all things (1 Corinthians 13:4-13).(copyright © 2021 Servants of the Word, source:  dailyscripture.net, author Don Schwager).

"Nor was Mary below what was becoming the mother of Christ. When the apostles fled, she stood at the cross and with pious eyes beheld her Son's wounds. For she did not look to the death of her offspring but to the salvation of the world. Or perhaps, because that 'royal hall' [Mary as bearer of the divine King] knew that the redemption of the world would be through the death of her Son, she thought that by her death she also might add something to that universal gift. But Jesus did not need a helper for the redemption of all, who saved all without a helper. This is why he says, 'I am counted among those who go down to the pit. I am like those who have no help' (Psalm 88:4-5). He received indeed the affection of his mother but sought not anothers help. Imitate her, holy mothers, who in her only dearly beloved Son set forth so great an example of maternal virtue. For neither have you sweeter children, nor did the Virgin seek the consolation of being able to bear another son." (excerpt from LETTER 63.109-11)6 

The Word Among Us Meditation on John 19:25-27 comments that Mary was no stranger to sorrow when she received the lifeless body of her son on Good Friday, and Michelangelo’s sculpture, the Pietà, captures this familiarity beautifully. For Mary had learned the secret to sorrow and grief—that it is not permanent. Her near divorce ended with Joseph deeply committed to her and her son. In the cave, she was surrounded by shepherds telling of angelic choirs. When Jesus left to preach and teach, she found a new role in a large family made up of everyone who “does the will of God” (Mark 3:35).

Somehow Mary knew—she believed—that her son’s death on the cross was not the end. So even as she grieved all that he had endured, even as she felt each of his pains as if it were her own, she trusted that God would not leave her and that her grief would eventually turn to joy. So will yours. And as you wait, you can lean on Mary as your own tender, compassionate Mother. “Holy Mary, Our Lady of Sorrows, pray for us!”7 

Friar Jude Winkler comments that the Letter to Timothy (USCCB selection) exhorts the community to act consistent with what they are. Mary and the beloved disciple, under the Cross, resonate with the Levirate marriage custom  as the beloved disciple marries the Church (widow Mary) to raise up “children” for Christ. Friar Jude reminds us of the sword (the Work) that pierces the understanding of a young Jewish woman intimately familiar with praying the Shema.


 

Fr. Richard Rohr, OFM, introduces Elizabeth Johnson, brilliant theologian, Sister of St. Joseph, and professor at Fordham University, who has written extensively about the universal nature of salvation— not only for humans, but for all creation. By focusing our religious conversations on the problem of human sin and “worthiness,” we have often lost sight of the strong scriptural evidence for the universal return of all of creation to God.

Biblical writers elaborated the good news using concepts of liberation, reconciliation, justification, victory over the powers, living in peace, fullness of life, being freed from slavery, adoption, and new birth as God’s children to name but a few. These long-untapped resources . . . open doors to understanding more varied dimensions of what is meant by the mystery of redemption. One result has been renewed awareness of New Testament texts about cosmic redemption that previously just flew by. These texts that extend the promise of a future to all of creation are few in number, but they are strong. . . . The great hymn in Colossians (Colossians 1:15–20)  which draws on the Wisdom tradition and the history of Jesus in equal measure, is suffused with this insight.8
 

The Memorial of Our Lady of Sorrows is an opportunity to bring our experience of sorrow to the Cross as the Spirit revives our faith, hope, and love.

 

References

1

(n.d.). Hebrews, CHAPTER 5 | USCCB. Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://bible.usccb.org/bible/hebrews/5 


2

(n.d.). Psalm 31 - USCCB. Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://bible.usccb.org/bible/psalms/31 


3

(n.d.). Luke, CHAPTER 2 | USCCB. Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://bible.usccb.org/bible/luke/2 


4

(n.d.). John, CHAPTER 19 | USCCB. Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://bible.usccb.org/bible/john/19 


5

(n.d.). Creighton U Daily Reflections - Online Ministries. Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://onlineministries.creighton.edu/CollaborativeMinistry/091521.html 


6

(n.d.). Daily Scripture Readings and Meditations. Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://www.dailyscripture.net/daily-meditation/?ds_year=2021&date=sep15a 


7

(2021, September 15). Our Lady of Sorrows (Memorial) - Mass Readings and Catholic Daily .... Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://wau.org/meditations/2021/09/15/199688/ 


8

(n.d.). Daily Meditations Archive: 2021 - Center for Action and Contemplation. Retrieved September 15, 2021, from https://cac.org/universal-salvation-of-all-creation-2021-09-15/